An argument that abortion is wrong don marquis
Don marquis (born 1935) is an marquis is best known for his paper why abortion is immoral, this paper has been reprinted over 80 times, and is widely cited in the philosophical debate over abortion the main argument in the paper is sometimes known as the deprivation argument, since a central premise is that abortion deprives an. The claim that abortion, except perhaps in rare instances, is seriously wrong the argument will establish that abortion is wrong for the same reason as killing a reader of this essay. This week i will be critiquing don marquis’ classic bioethics paper: “why abortion is immoral” the paper was published in 1989 and to this day it remains one of the most-discussed articles in the debate on abortion.
Don marquis' why abortion is immoral in his essay why abortion is immoral, don marquis argues against the morality of abortion on the premise that the value of a fetus' future is so great that it is immoral to take that potential future away from it. Don marquis’ “why abortion is immoral” is almost as prominent within introductory-level ethics courses as the title implies, marquis offers a counter to thomson’s position, though the interesting thing is thomson and marquis make argumentative moves that disallow them from being able to engage with each other directly. Why abortion is immoral by don marquis essay - why abortion is immoral by don marquis is an essay that claims that abortion is morally wrong, and uses one argument in particular to explain why. Lecture 5 notes: judith jarvis thomson and don marquis judith jarvis thompsons “a defense of abortion” the standard argument against abortion rests on the claim that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to life.
Don marquis, in why abortion is immoral,' argues that abortion is, except possibly in rare cases, seriously immoral, that it is in the same moral category as killing an innocent human being (183. Daniel j hill: ticking bombs, torture, and the analogy with self-defense. I disagree with marquis but this seems like a very strong argument i think the only possible weak points are in his personal conception of why killing is morally wrong and in him establishing that a fetus has those future experiences that he claims abortion takes away. Marquis's argument is one of the most plausible arguments that would establish that embryo destruction is wrong in sum, marquis establishes an argument that there are reasons against having an abortion (and by extension to contraception and embryo research.
I think it is because his best philosophical argument for why abortion is immoral can also be used to argue that it is moral i just finished writing an answer for another marquis-related question and this one popped up for me, so i will paste in what i wrote: i have just now read don marquis. The argument against abortion: marquis concludes that his explanation of the wrongness of killing is best, and therefore that any action that deprives an individual of a valuable future is prima facie seriously wrong. Don marquis has the best argument for why abortion is immoral he says that if you believe it is wrong to kill a normal adult human being then you should also believe it is wrong to abort a human fetus.
262 life and learning xvi 11 dean stretton, “the deprivation argument against abortion,” p 150 12 don marquis, “an argument that abortion is wrong,” p 91 a 90-year old may value his future just as much as (or more than) when he was 30, while still acknowledging that, objectively speaking, his pool of. To develop an argument on the unethical nature of abortion, don marquis states that we must ask the question of why it is morally wrong to kill someone marquis determines that what makes killing wrong is the effect that it has on the victim itself. Opposing arguments: abortion introduction: why abortion is immoral by don marquis is the start of two discussions pertaining to whether abortion should be acceptable in our modern society the argument, marquis makes, is that abortion actually deprives the fetus’s “future-like-ours. This is marquis' argument, which is the argument we considered today according to marquis, abortion is seriously morally wrong because it is an act of killing a being with a right to life and killing a being with a right to life is seriously morally wrong because it robs such a being of its future--a future, in particular, of great value like. Marquis: “ this argument does not rely on the invalid inference that, since it is wrong to kill persons, it is wrong to kill potential persons also the category that is morally central to this analysis is the category of having a valuable future like ours it is not the category of personhood.
An argument that abortion is wrong don marquis
A seminal essay by don marquis argues that abortion is wrong because it deprives the embryo of a valuable future marquis begins by arguing that what makes it wrong to kill a normal adult human being is the fact that the killing inflicts a terrible harm on the victim. Don marquis: why abortion is immoral i marquis' main goal the purpose of this essay is to develop a general argument for the claim that the overwhelming majority of deliberate abortions are seriously immoral (183. Don marquis ~ an argument that abortion is wrong therefore abortion is almost always wrong _____ four arguments against marquis: the problem here is like the problem with the potentiality argument to do wrong, we must deprive an actual individual of their likely future to do wrong, there must be an actual individual whom we wrong.
The first is judith jarvis thomson’s “a defense of abortion,” and the second is don marquis’s “why abortion is immoral” i’ll explain why i think thomson is wrong and marquis is. A review of why abortion is immoral commenter publius pointed me to this paper by don marquis , which advances a secular argument that abortion is immoral it's a good paper with an unusually well-reasoned -- though nonetheless incorrect -- argument. Don marquis’s purpose to his essay is to set out to prove that abortion is seriously wrong he is addressing that abortion is morally wrong and should not be permitted except in certain cases the authors thesis is “abortion, except perhaps in rare instances, is seriously wrong”(marquis, 754.
Don marquis, an argument that abortion is wrong don marquis, an argument that abortion is wrong according to marquis, why is killing a fetus wrong killing a fetus deprives it of a future like ours so it is prima facie wrong marquis's idea could be disproved if there was a different reason that death was wrong what are two possibilities. Don marquis has famously argued that abortion is wrong because it deprives the foetus of a future-like-ours in this post i will not examine his basic argument but look at an objection which is widely seen as showing that it is unsound. Why abortion is immoral by don marquis is the discussion of whether abortion should be acceptable in our society in this paper, i will argue against his defense of anti-abortion first, i will show that the fetus is not considered human, so marquis’ strategy of determining what makes killing wrong in general and applying the same reasoning.